
Ashton Coleman, Broker Associate, ONE Sotheby’s International Realty
📞 305.978.7704 · 📧 AColeman@onesothebysrealty.com
The Short Answer
Across 860 Miami closings of $1,000,000 and above that I have measured directly, sellers took a median 93.4% of their final asking price and 90.0% of the price they first asked.
Almost every market report publishes the first number. Almost none publish the second. The 3.4 point difference between them is the reductions a seller takes before any buyer makes an offer, and it is the part of the story that disappears from the record once a listing is reduced.
But the average is the least useful thing here, because the sellers in this dataset split almost evenly into two groups that behave nothing alike.
Fifty-two percent never reduced at all. For them the two figures are identical and the gap is zero. Forty-eight percent did reduce, and those sellers gave up a median of 7.0 points between their first asking price and their last, with a quarter of them giving up more than 12.1 points and the worst case reaching 42.0.
So the honest answer to how much below asking a Miami property sells is not three points. It is that roughly half of sellers get close to their number, and the other half cut their price by seven points before negotiation even starts.
What separates the two groups is almost entirely the first ninety days. Among properties that went under contract inside 90 days, 75% never reduced and sellers took 92.5% of their original asking price. Among those that took 180 to 364 days, only 35% never reduced and sellers took 88.0%.
The Two Numbers, and Why Only One Gets Published
Every closed sale carries two asking prices. The original list price is what the seller first asked. The list price is what they were asking when the contract was signed. If the seller never reduced, those are the same figure. If they did, the original is higher, sometimes much higher.
The statistic the industry reports, sale price to list price, uses the second one. It is accurate and it is incomplete, because it measures the discount from a number that has already absorbed every reduction the seller made. A seller who asked $5,000,000, cut to $4,400,000 over eight months and closed at $4,250,000 appears in the standard statistic at 96.6% of asking. Against what they originally wanted, they got 85.0%.
Both figures are true. Only one of them describes what happened.
| Measure | Pooled result, 860 closings |
|---|---|
| Sold to final list price | 93.4% |
| Sold to original list price | 90.0% |
| Difference | 3.4 points |
| Sellers who never reduced | 52% |
| Sellers who reduced before contract | 48% |
| Median reduction among those who reduced | 7.0 points |
| Upper quarter of reducers | more than 12.1 points |
| Largest reduction in the dataset | 42.0 points |
Half Never Reduce, and the Other Half Cut Seven Points
The 3.4 point pooled gap is a blend of 448 closings where the gap was zero and 411 where it ran about seven points. Those 859 are the closings carrying a usable original list price, one short of the 860 in the pooled figures. Reporting the result as a single average describes almost nobody in either group.
This matters most when a seller is deciding where to open. A seller who prices correctly has a better than even chance of never reducing at all, and the figure that applies to them is 93.4% of asking. A seller who opens high enters a group whose median outcome is a seven point haircut on the asking price before a buyer has made a single offer, and then a further negotiation from there.
It also matters to a buyer reading comparables. A comparable quoted at 96% of asking tells you nothing about whether that seller started 15% higher. The original list price is the only way to see it, and it is in the MLS record for anyone whose agent pulls it.
The First Ninety Days Decide It
| Days to contract | Closings | Sold to final list | Sold to original list | Gap | Share that never reduced |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under 90 days | 266 | 93.7% | 92.5% | 1.2 | 75% |
| 90 to 179 days | 186 | 93.1% | 89.0% | 4.1 | 44% |
| 180 to 364 days | 244 | 93.0% | 88.0% | 5.0 | 35% |
| 365 to 729 days | 118 | 92.8% | 90.0% | 2.8 | 47% |
| 730 days and up | 31 | 92.7% | 86.0% | 6.7 | 39% |
The break is sharp and it is in one place. Properties that go under contract inside ninety days get 92.5% of their original asking price, and three quarters of them never reduce. Everything past ninety days looks different: the never-reduced share drops by roughly half and sellers land between 86.0% and 90.0%.
Read the final list column alongside it, because it is the control. It barely moves, running between 92.7% and 93.7% across every band. A property that sits for two years does not get a worse deal relative to its final asking price. It gets the same deal, from a much lower asking price. The damage happens in the reductions, not at the closing table.
One band breaks the pattern and I am not going to smooth it over. The 365 to 729 day group shows a 2.8 point gap, narrower than the band below it, on 118 closings. Some of that is properties relisted after a break, which resets how the days accumulate. The sharp, reliable finding here is the line at ninety days. The ordering beyond it is noisier than a clean gradient.
The Concession Changes Shape as the Price Rises
| Price band | Closings | Sold to final list | Sold to original list | Gap | Share that never reduced |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $1M to $2M | 304 | 94.0% | 91.0% | 3.0 | 51% |
| $2M to $4M | 263 | 92.9% | 90.0% | 2.9 | 49% |
| $4M to $8M | 196 | 93.6% | 91.0% | 2.6 | 52% |
| $8M to $15M | 57 | 92.0% | 90.0% | 2.0 | 61% |
| Above $15M | 40 | 89.0% | 88.0% | 1.0 | 68% |
Two columns move in opposite directions as the price rises, and together they describe a change in how sellers concede.
The share who never reduce climbs from 51% to 68%. Trophy sellers hold their asking price. They are less likely to be carrying a mortgage that forces a decision, more able to wait, and often advised that a visible reduction damages the property’s standing.
And the sale against the final asking price falls from 94.0% to 89.0%. They hold the number and then take 11% off it in negotiation.
So the entry market and the trophy market arrive at a similar place by opposite routes. Below $4 million, a seller cuts the asking price publicly and then closes near it. Above $15 million, a seller holds the asking price and absorbs the concession privately, at the table. The published statistic captures the second kind and misses the first, which is exactly backwards from where most buyers assume the negotiating room sits.
Six Markets, Same Direction
This is not one measurement. I have now run it six times, on six separate datasets, and it has pointed the same way every time.
| Market | Sold to final list | Sold to original list | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coconut Grove condos | 95.2% | 93.0% | 2.2 |
| Oceana Bal Harbour | 93.5% | 91.0% | 2.5 |
| New-construction coastal houses | 93.4% | 91.0% | 2.4 |
| Sunny Isles Beach condos | 93.5% | 90.0% | 3.5 |
| Continuum South Beach | 92.3% | 89.0% | 3.3 |
| New-construction condos | 93.2% | 89.0% | 4.2 |
The gap runs between 2.2 and 4.2 points depending on the market, and it has never once run the other way. A single building, a neighbourhood, a product type and a county-wide pull all produce the same result.
That consistency is the argument. One measurement can be an artifact of a dataset. Six measurements across single buildings, neighbourhoods, new construction and resale, condominiums and houses, describing the same gap in the same direction, is a property of how the market reports itself.
What This Means If You Are Buying
Ask for the original list price on every comparable, not the reduced one. Your agent can pull it in the same search that produced the comparable. Most reports do not include it, and in 48% of these closings it is materially different from the figure you were shown.
A comparable that sold at 96% of asking may have sold at 84% of what the seller wanted. That tells you something about the building, the floor plan or the price level that the headline figure conceals.
A long listing is a different negotiation from a fresh one, but not in the way most buyers think. A property that has sat 300 days is not going to take a bigger cut off its current asking price. It has already taken the cut. The current price is the result of the negotiation you assumed you were about to have.
Above $8 million, expect the room to be at the table rather than in the asking price. Sixty-eight percent of sellers above $15 million never reduced, and they closed at 89.0% of what they were asking.
What This Means If You Are Selling
Price for the first ninety days. It is the single most consequential decision in the process. Sell inside ninety days and the median outcome is 92.5% of your original asking price with a 75% chance of never reducing. Miss that window and the median drops to between 86.0% and 89.0%.
An aspirational asking price is not free. It does not sit harmlessly while you wait for the right buyer. It puts you in the half of the market that cuts a median seven points, and the price you end up accepting is measured from the reduced number, not the original one.
Reducing does not recover the position. Sale to final asking price barely moves across any time band, 92.7% to 93.7%. Cutting the price does not get you a better deal relative to the new number. It just lowers the number.
If you are above $8 million, holding the asking price is defensible. Most sellers at that level do, and the evidence supports it, provided you are prepared for the concession to arrive in negotiation instead. Plan for 89.0% of your asking price rather than 96%.
One market shows how little the concession tells you on its own. Across 1,368 coastal condominium sales in buildings that permit nightly rental, the median closing took 92.0% of its original asking price whether the building was delivered before or after 2019, yet the newer buildings failed to sell 55.8% of the time against 25.5% for the older ones. The concession was identical. The odds of getting to one were not. That comparison is in Miami Condo Hotels 2026.

Frequently Asked Questions
How much below asking do Miami condos sell for?
About 10% below the original asking price and about 7% below the final asking price. Across 860 Miami closings of $1,000,000 and above, the median sale took 93.4% of the final list price and 90.0% of the price the seller first asked. The difference between those two figures is the reductions taken before any offer arrived.
What is the difference between list price and original list price?
The original list price is what the seller first asked. The list price is what they were asking when a contract was signed. If the seller reduced at any point, the two differ, and the standard sale-to-list statistic uses the second one, which has already absorbed every reduction. In 48% of these closings the two figures were materially different.
Do most Miami sellers reduce their price?
Slightly fewer than half. Fifty-two percent of these 860 sellers never reduced at all. The 48% who did reduce cut a median of 7.0 points from their original asking price, with the upper quarter cutting more than 12.1 points and the largest single reduction reaching 42.0 points.
How long does it take to sell a Miami property above $1 million?
The more useful question is what happens either side of ninety days. Properties under contract within 90 days took 92.5% of their original asking price and 75% of them never reduced. Properties taking 180 to 364 days took 88.0%, and only 35% never reduced. The sale price relative to the final asking price barely changes across those bands, which means the difference is made in the reductions, not at the closing table.
Do luxury Miami sellers negotiate more than entry-level sellers?
They negotiate differently. Above $15 million, 68% of sellers never reduced their asking price, against 51% below $2 million. But those same trophy sellers closed at 89.0% of their final asking price against 94.0% in the entry market. The lower end cuts the asking price publicly. The top end holds it and concedes in negotiation.
Why do market reports not publish the original list price?
Because the standard statistic, sale price to list price, was defined that way and has been reported that way for decades. The original figure is in the MLS record and any agent can pull it. It just is not what the headline number measures.
Is a property that has been listed a long time a better deal?
Not relative to its current asking price. Across every time band, sales land between 92.7% and 93.7% of the final asking price, so a two-year listing does not concede more from where it now sits. It concedes more from where it started, which means the discount is already reflected in the price you are looking at.
What should a Miami seller expect to get?
If the property goes under contract inside ninety days, about 92.5% of the original asking price. If it takes longer, between 86.0% and 90.0%. If the property is above $8 million, plan on roughly 89.0% to 90.0% of the asking price with a good chance of never needing a public reduction.
Does this pattern hold across different Miami markets?
Yes, in every market measured so far. The gap between sale-to-final-list and sale-to-original-list runs 2.2 points in Coconut Grove, 2.4 for new-construction coastal houses, 2.5 at Oceana Bal Harbour, 3.3 at Continuum South Beach, 3.5 in Sunny Isles Beach and 4.2 for new-construction condominiums. Six separate datasets, six times the same direction, and not once the reverse.
How do I find the original list price on a property?
Ask the agent representing you to include it in the comparable search. It is a standard MLS field. If a comparable is quoted to you without it, that is worth asking about rather than assuming.
Buying or Selling in Miami?
What a property will actually sell for cannot be read off a sale-to-list statistic. It depends on where the asking price started rather than where it ended, how long comparable properties took to go under contract, whether the sellers of those comparables reduced and by how much, how the price level you are in tends to concede, and whether the room in a particular negotiation sits in the asking price or at the table.
If you’re buying or selling anywhere from Brickell and Edgewater through Miami Beach, Surfside, Bal Harbour, Sunny Isles Beach, Aventura, Golden Beach or Fort Lauderdale, contact Ashton Coleman for a comparison built on original asking prices rather than reduced ones.
Explore current listings on MiamiPenthousesandEstates.com.
📞 305.978.7704
📧 AColeman@onesothebysrealty.com

About the Market Data
The pooled figures here rest on 860 closed sales of $1,000,000 and above, drawn from three Southeast Florida MLS exports and recomputed for this analysis: 418 Sunny Isles Beach condominium sales closing between January 2025 and October 2026, 264 Miami-Dade new-construction condominium sales closing in 2024 or later, and 178 new-construction coastal single-family sales closing in 2024 or later. Each of those three datasets has its own published analysis and the figures here match those posts.
Three of the six markets in the replication table, Coconut Grove, Oceana Bal Harbour and Continuum South Beach, are cited from their own published analyses rather than recomputed here, because they come from exports covering those markets specifically. The three recomputed datasets are the ones carrying the pooled figures, the price bands and the time bands.
Pooling three exports is not the same as one county-wide pull, and the pooled figure is weighted toward Sunny Isles and new construction because those are the datasets in hand. The replication argument does not depend on the pooled number. It depends on the six markets pointing the same direction independently, which they do.
Sold to original list price uses the MLS SP/OLP field. A small number of records carry impossible values in that field, such as a ratio above 9, and are excluded from discount measures. “Never reduced” means the sale-to-final-list and sale-to-original-list figures agree within half a percentage point, which captures sellers who never changed the price and a small number whose change was negligible. Days on market uses the cumulative figure, which counts a property’s full history across relistings rather than only its current listing, and that is why the 365 to 729 day band behaves less predictably than the others.
Sample sizes are shown in every table. The two smallest, 40 closings above $15 million and 31 closings beyond 730 days, describe those sales rather than their categories. MLS information is believed accurate but is not guaranteed.
Disclaimer
Information is provided for informational purposes only and is subject to change without notice. Real estate statistics, listings and sales information should be independently verified. Nothing contained herein constitutes legal, tax, financial or investment advice. Buyers and sellers should consult appropriate professional advisors before making real estate decisions.
